If a tenant is violating the lease, the landlord serves a notice. Sometimes it’s a three day notice to pay rent or move. Sometimes it’s a seven day notice to correct a problem and not do it again. Sometimes it’s a notice to vacate.
Landlords often worry that the tenant who receives such a notice will claim a violation of fair housing law. It is thus not surprising that some landlords hesitate to take any action, even though the noncompliance persists.
A landlord protects himself by being sure that his decision to serve a notice or to start an eviction is based solely on non-discriminatory reasons. The decision can never be based, even in part, on the tenant’s race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or handicap. [Don’t forget – Your local government may have added one or two to that list.]
As long as the landlord is not considering the tenant’s protected class, it is okay to evict a tenant. There must be valid, nondiscriminatory reasons for the eviction. It is okay to evict a tenant who fails to pay rent regardless of the tenant’s protected status. A landlord could cross the line, though, if he treats one group of non-payers differently from another group of non-payers. For instance, if the landlord generally serves three day notices on the 10th of each month, but serves three day notices to families with children on the 5th of each month, then the landlord should expect a fair housing complaint to be made.
Here are some other situations that can result in discrimination complaints:
A single woman is told that her partner is approved to move in with her, and then is evicted when management learns her partner is of a different race.
A married couple who lives in a one bedroom apartment is asked to vacate after management learns the wife is pregnant.
Tenants who invited guests of a particular racial, ethnic or religious group for dinner or an afternoon at the pool are asked to vacate.
A tenant with epilepsy falls at the property and has a seizure. The ensuing flurry of emergency personnel causes the landlord to issue a disturbance notice.